Live music is better than recorded music. It’s a given. Having that connection, where you’re sharing the same space as the artist is a unique experience that can’t be replicated on a plastic disc. To receive the gift from the giver personally is a moment of intimacy not possible if it arrives in a package in the mail. To be able to garner instantaneous gratitude, be it by applause, cheers or a smile is the reward that the artist lives for, else they wouldn’t be there. Showing appreciation for the gift returns the favour in kind. The performance feeds the audience, and vice versa.

Vinyl records hold the same sort of appeal that steel bicycles do; both materials revolutionised their respective industries and held the mantle of the best, the only choice, for decades. Then both were usurped by smaller, lighter composite materials and while the convenience and perceived performance they offered took over on a wholesale scale, a handful of purists held on to their Electric Ladyland limited edition LPs along with their Colnago Masters and Merckx Leaders. Vinyl may have been suddenly deemed cumbersome, inconvenient to use and harder to source, but it still offered a timeless sound quality that just had something about it, something that CDs and MP3s would struggle to achieve.

Same with steel bikes. There’s an indisputable and indescribable feeling that comes in the first few pedal strokes on a steel bike, and like pulling out that dog-eared copy of Hunky Dory, you know exactly what you’ll be getting, and you’re gonna like it. Picking up a hand-built bike from the person who made it is like going down to the studio to grab a signed slab of wax that Nick Cave hands to you himself. Straight to you.

Where the vinyl record remains round, grooved and black, the steel bicycle’s tubes remain round, straight and flat. You can’t improve on what’s proven. What’s perfect. Only the touch of the hand of the artist can make each one unique, where things that are really just simple things (a record, a bicycle) can be themselves set apart by the signatures laid upon them by their creators, curating originality (Jagger, Jaegher). To say it’s pretty special to see your own bicycle being made, your name on the tubes as they come together to be joined forever by the heat of the torch and the deft touch of the electrode, would be a modest assessment. To finally ride it, might be impossible to describe.

Brett

Don't blame me

View Comments

  • @Jaegher

    Apologies if my post implied any knock against TIG welding. That was certainly not intended. I am just a very excited devotee to Don Walker's work as I have 4 of his frames. He prefers filet brazing so and all of his frames are constructed as such( although he does do lugged if requested). I have a pair of TIG welded beauties in my fleet currently a matching TI and Steel set of frames made by Seven. I also await another TIG'ed beauty...a Big Leg Emma from Dario Pegoretti

  • @Jaegher

    @wilburrox

    It all depends on how and how much the frame will be used and where. If you ride a lot in the rain etc it might be useful to spray some WD-40 or similar inside from time to time. Grease between the seatpost and seat tube will keep most of the water out if redone regularly.

    I sure appreciate that perspective. Thank you. When speaking with the folks at LBS I'd said I wanted to see the frame first before we did anything. The thought of gunking up the frame, even if on inside, kinda permanently ? But I've not seen the stuff applied. My bikes do get wet and muddy and they also get regular TLC. This will be the CX bike for '15 season. I have a 30+ year old CroMoly frame/bike that has never been treated and is in decent shape.

  • @Teocalli

    What collection of tubes will steel#2 be made from? Modern large diameter thin wall? Retro skinny and lugged? I'm interested to hear the fourth data point. I'm betting it will be between the two carbon points if its modern stuff.

  • @Roger

    You cannot tune the ride characteristics of other materials like you can a custom steel frame. My last custom steel frame, the builder choose tubing type and thicknesses and other various details, riding style etc. to build a frame tuned to how I wanted the bike handle and ride, and that is exactly what I got, your not getting that with other materials

    I just snorted my coffee. Choosing tubing type and thickness is just about the peak of what you can vary on a steel frame, which is nothing compared to the possibilities that engineered composites have. Claiming the opposite is just laughable.

  • @Oli

    @TommyTubolare

    I don’t know how you got that I was somehow criticising other materials because I’m not at all! Even though my steel frame is stiff, it’s certainly not light, so I’d never claim that it’s “better” than another frame made of a different material. I agree entirely that carbon has many benefits that steel can’t duplicate, and I’m not foolish enough to try and claim that any material is superior in every application anyway.

    My (I thought clearly stated) point is that geometry isn’t the only predicator of ride quality; that materials, dimensions and finishing kit also have an effect. I don’t think there can be any rational dispute about this.

    To that point, the wheels are the item that impacts the ride more than any other single factor; I had Ksyriums on my TSX and is sucked the life out of the frame. Putting some 3x tubs on there turned it into a butter yet lively ride.

    Same for my carbon frames; I have climbing wheels, flying wheels and 3x box sections (Golden Tickets) and all three completely change the nature of the machine.

  • @Oli

    I don't know either Oli, but if I did my apologies.

    On the other hand I never said that geometry is the only important thing because it clearly isn't.

    All I did is noticed in this thread that steel was somehow given these superior properties that actually cannot be applied to steel, hence my disagreeing posts.

  • @DavidB

    @Teocalli

    What collection of tubes will steel#2 be made from? Modern large diameter thin wall? Retro skinny and lugged? I’m interested to hear the fourth data point. I’m betting it will be between the two carbon points if its modern stuff.

    It's not custom, it's the NOS Pinarello Sestriere that I posted some Pics of a while back under Bikes.  So it's lugless and a mix of tube shapes mostly round with a formed downtube.  Tubing is Pinerallo's own spec from that era.

Share
Published by
Brett

Recent Posts

Anatomy of a Photo: Sock & Shoe Game

I know as well as any of you that I've been checked out lately, kind…

7 years ago

Velominati Super Prestige: Men’s World Championship Road Race 2017

Peter Sagan has undergone quite the transformation over the years; starting as a brash and…

7 years ago

Velominati Super Prestige: Women’s World Championship Road Race 2017

The Women's road race has to be my favorite one-day road race after Paris-Roubaix and…

7 years ago

Velominati Super Prestige: Vuelta a España 2017

Holy fuckballs. I've never been this late ever on a VSP. I mean, I've missed…

7 years ago

Velominati Super Prestige: Clasica Ciclista San Sebastian 2017

This week we are currently in is the most boring week of the year. After…

7 years ago

Route Finding

I have memories of my life before Cycling, but as the years wear slowly on…

7 years ago